Long rumored to be the possible inspiration for the book of mormon, the late. Book of mormon and late war comparison mormonleaks. There are too many other echoes of indian history and tradition for anybody to attribute the similarities to pure chance. Essentially the argument against the book of mormon goes something like this. Did joseph smith plagiarize the book of mormon from gilbert j. The war of 1812 has also been called the 2nd war of independence because it settled once and for all the sovereinty of the united states of. Its something thats been studied by eran shalevhe wrote a book called american zionand hes a professor nonlds at the history department at haifa, israel. The late war between the united states and great britain is an educational text written by gilbert j. The late war is essentially a history book about the war of 1812. These range from wellknown wars, such as the war of 1812, the mexican war, the spanishamerican war, and world war i, to the battles that were peculiarly missourian, including the heatherly war of 1836, the mormon war of 1838, and the iowa honey war of 1839. Harris enlists in the thirtyninth new york militia and is eventually promoted to first sergeant. Lewis 6 caring for the poor 11 charts 21 chiasmus 8 christmas 7. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Hunt and it heavily influenced his writing of the book of mormon.
Much more than simply reporting these wars like a modern journalist, mormon infused moral and theological. Did joseph smith steal from the late war to write the book of. The late war, between the united states and great britain. Oct 30, 20 the rediscovery of the late war by gilbert hunt recently as a possible source for understanding the language, style, and narrative content of the book of mormon has already elicited a considerable. Book of mormon, history of warfare in the encyclopedia of. The late war, between the united states and great britain, from. There is an entire book of warfare in the book of mormon that only partially explores the deep warrelated content of that ancient book. The chapter on warfare in john sorensons recent mormons codex.
The late war uses words or phrases that also appear in the. Philip was a soldier in the new york militia in the war of 1812. The public perception was that america won the war of 1812. This put the british empire in its place once again. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading war of 1812. War the church of jesus christ of latterday saints. The latter is a history of the war of 1812 deliberately written in a scriptural style. An assumption is being made that joseph smith must have read gilbert hunts the late war in the absence of any evidence to support it. A history from beginning to end kindle edition by history, hourly. The late war between the united states and great britain is a book about the war of 1812 written in the style of the king james bible published in 1816.
Out of the top matches, we discovered a book called the late war between the united states and great britain, a scriptural style account of the war of 1812 published in new york in 1816. It was written in biblical prose, and many of the passages have striking. When translation of the book was completed, joseph smith had trouble finding a printer who would undertake publication. Believers in a miraculous origin for the book of mormon. While many of the realities of war apply to any setting, including the war of 1812, much of what is in the book of mormon has an ancient flavor that joseph could not have fabricated. He studied american texts that were written like the bible, and the late war falls in this genre. Joseph obtains the book of mormon plates from angel moroni at hill cumorah. Book of mormonplagiarism accusationsthe late war fair. This is not a proof that the book of mormon events happened in north america, but it is a very powerful indication that these native americans have incredibly similar stories as found in the story of the book of mormon. Military records, 1812 1904, has records related to. The late war between the united states and great britain.
An update to the research the wordtree foundation has been doing on the book of mormon and the late war between the united states and great britain. Pierre berton transforms history into an engrossing narrative that reads like a fastpaced novel. What year was the book of mormon written, and was it written. The first chapter 45 alone is stunning as it reads incredibly like the book of mormon. If you will give up mormonism and that book of mormon, you are welcome to.
The late war, the book of mormon, and big data duane. Its rather a stretch in this context to say that derivation from a common source will result in two things more similar to each other than either is to the source. Such an issue is the recent claim that an 1816 scripturalstyle history of the war of 1812 entitled the late war between the united states and great britain lw had an influence on the book of mormon. If you havent seen this information be prepared to have your mind blown. Below you will find many references to this sacred book or the lamanite traditions about this book. The invasion of canada is a remarkable account of the war s first year and the events that led up to it. The book of mormon and the book, the late war comparison. As is true today, warfare in the ancient world took on ideological importance for both sides of a conflict. Why are there so many war chapters in the book of mormon. The late war is an account of the war of 1812 written in the style of the king james bible. He became a property owner, weaver, and sheep raiser. Between 1817 and 1819 it was marketed for the use of schools throughout the united states under the title the historical reader. Missouri territory in the war of 1812 familysearch. He fought on the front lines against the british near the canadian border.
The late war the late war is an account of the war of 1812 which is written in the style of the king james bible. The second edition was marketed as a textbook, where the title was changed to the historical reader. To commemorate the bicentenary of the war of 1812, anchor canada brings together pierre bertons two groundbreaking books on the subject. President james madison signed the declaration commencing the war of 1812 with britain. Martin was reared to maturity in palmyra, new york. Long rumored to be the possible inspiration for the book of mormon, the late war is a classic piece of american literature that you should consider reading. The grim reality for ancient peoples was that religious, political, and cultural ideologies were frequently enforced through war. Wars and destructions were brought upon the nephites because of the contentions, murderings, idolatry, whoredoms, and abominations which were among themselves, while those who were faithful in keeping the commandments of the lord were delivered at all times from captivity, death. This american childrens textbook describing the war of 1812 is filled with book of mormon parallels, including many striking hebraisms which meet examples offered by some book of mormon defenders as evidence of an underlying ancient hebrew text. It was a historical account of the thenrecent war of 1812, written in the scriptural style. Mar 12, 2014 despite this, the book of nullification is nearly twice as similar to the book of mormon as the book of mormon is to the late war. The book of mormon s stories of lamanites and king men sound much like britishindian cooperation during the revolutionary war and the war of 1812. In the subsequent battle, the battle of lake erie, perrys flagship, the lawrence, was reduced to ruins, but he transferred his flag to the niagara and shortly.
Sep 01, 2010 the story line for the book of mormon probably came from ethan smiths, 1823 new york novel, view of the hebrews elder b. In the war of 1812 he was commissioned to build, equip, and man a fleet at erie, pa. Aug 03, 2011 the book of mormon is really a clever adaptation of an obscure, unpublished historical novel written during the war of 1812 in conneaut, oh and pittsburgh, pa by a downandout expreacher named solomon spalding, a revolutionary war veteran and bankrupt land speculator who died at amity, washington county, pa in 1816 and lies buried in the. I will discuss only the statistical model presented by the johnsons here.
The late war is an account of the war of 1812 which is written in the style of the king james bible. If latterday saints are called upon to go into battle, they can look to the example of captain moroni, the great military leader in the book of mormon. Andrew jackson became a war hero, and was regarded by many as the man who won the war. The late war against the book of mormon the interpreter. The authors have spent decades collecting and analyzing evidence to conclude that the book of mormon is an adaptation of an obscure historical novel written by revolutionary war veteran solomon spalding during the war of 1812. Measures approx 9x6 with 576 pages includes 3 maps, 2 full page, 22 hand colored illustrations. Podcasts to help people understand mormon s metaphor of war and how we can apply the lessons to our lives today.
The book of mormon teaches that war is a result of iniquity. Records alphabetical by surname, but not always in strict alphabetical order within each letter. Was the late war against the united states a source for the book. The united states, the british empire, and the war of 1812 by troy bickham, the civil war of 1812. Book of mormon central archive the late war between the united states and great britain, from june 1812 to february 1815. In the 21st century, speculation arose that the late war influenced the 1830 work the book of mormon. A traditional nonstatistical comparison between this text and the book of mormon was apparently introduced by rick grunder in his 2008 bibliography mormon parallels. Roberts, president of the first council of seventy after making an extensive study of the book concluded there was a great probability the smiths had a close encounter with view of the hebrews. The book depicted the events of the war of 1812 and it was specifically written in a jacobean english style to imitate the king james bible. However, perception is often more important than reality. Aug 03, 2016 the book of mormon is a book saturated with warfare. The solomon spalding manuscript 1812 by solomon spalding this unpublished manuscript was a work of fiction created by a retired minister, solomon spalding who died in 1816 before being able to publish his work.
Paid the printing costs for the publication of the book of mormon through the sale of 151 acres of his farm. In 1792, tecumseh, then known as ryegate postal station, had only three families. Warfare in the book of mormon byu scholarsarchive brigham. May 18, 1783 july 10, 1875 farmer, weaver, sheep raiser, and veteran of the war of 1812. In 1819 he was appointed an overseer of highways and a fence viewer in junius, suggesting that philip was a landed gentry. The late war, the book of mormon, and big data slideshare. May 27, 2011 the testimony of the three witnesses is printed in the book of mormon see book of mormon witnesses. This listing is for leather over board hardcover book shown.
The book depicted the events of the war of 1812 and it was. This new theory posits that joseph smith most likely grew up reading a school book called the late war by gilbert j. Did joseph smith plagiarize passages from gilbert hunts book the late war, between the united states and great britain, from june, 1812, to february. The 2008 work mormon parallels and a 2010 work have discussed possible similarities. The printers feared that local opposition would hurt sales. Book of mormon plagiarism theories and the late war.
He had a reputation in palmyra for being a gentleman and a farmer of respectability, as well as a patriot, having served in the ontario new york 39 th militia in the war of 1812. Martin harris timeline witnesses of the book of mormon. Native american sacred book book of mormon evidence. The late war uses words or phrases that also appear in the book of mormon. They assert that mormon founders sidney rigdon, oliver cowdery, and joseph smith jr. Barney, a veteran of both the war of 1812 and the black hawk war of 1832, died. The late war between the united states and great britain wikipedia. In october 20, the authors conducted a data analysis comparing the book of mormon to over 100,000 books from the pre1830s era. Ryegate postal station was renamed tecumseh in honour of tecumseh, leader of the shawnee tribe who was killed at battle in the war of 1812.
An ancient american book also should be read by anyone even mildly impressed with the late war as a possible explanation for the book of mormon. The late war between the united states and great britain, from. It includes entries for twelve wars and military engagements in which missouri soldiers took part. Its written in scriptural language and was published in 1816. An account of the war of 1812 written in the same style as the king james bible. In recent years, another theory for the origins of the book of mormon has emerged. The book of mormonis one book of several in this genre. Is the book of mormon like any other nineteenth century book. Chris johnson, duane johnson, in a comparison of the book of mormon and the late war between the united states and great britain, propose a number of parallel sentence structures between gilbert hunts book the late war and the book of mormon. In 20, the late war was the subject of discussion among both exmormons and mormon apologists. Why are there so many similarities in the book of mormon to the the late war between the united states.
1111 661 207 696 938 1670 1104 25 565 988 1190 546 862 1229 1365 1050 1380 173 976 1025 1110 1043 1160 796 661 13 1416 1445 1465 864 1787 1564 557 155 510 1462